MARRIAGE ALLIANCE:
THE UNION OF TWO IMPERIUMS, JAPAN AND ETHIOPIA?

Paper Presented to
The Annual Meeting
of the
Association for Third World Studies
San Jose, Costa Rica
November, 1999
J. Calvitt Clarke III
Jacksonville University

http://users.ju.edu/jclarke/wizzat2/html

Luke Roberts of the University of California at Santa Barbara tells a story. While in Japan, an old Japanese historian was driving him to an archive in Aki city in Kochi Prefecture. On the way, around Tei village, they saw a store advertising "Ethiopia Manjuu"—a shiny, brown, sweet, steamed dumpling stuffed with azuki bean paste. Told that Americans would consider such a name to be racist, the historian simply explained, "Oh, this local product was first developed in the 1930s, and the name was to show solidarity with the Ethiopian people."(1). How do we explain this seemingly odd connection between Japan in East Asia and Ethiopia in East Africa?

Italy, ruled by Benito Mussolini and his fascists, attacked Ethiopia on October 2, 1935, and in seven months conquered the country to create the Italian Empire. Italy’s military preparations before the attack had gone on in earnest for more than a year.  It resembled America’s military buildup before the Gulf War of 1991—especially for the sustained press coverage and intense, if not always earnest, multilateral diplomacy aimed at averting war. More earnestly, the two antagonists sought to find allies and undermine hostile coalitions. (2)

Of the many reasons that led Italy to decide for war, one stands out for its importance to contemporaries and for the oblivion later commentators consigned it. Japan’s real and perceived economic, political, and even military intrusions into its spheres of influence, including Ethiopia, upset Italy. (3) In early 1934, the Italia Marinara, the official publication of the Italian Navy League, put the matter plainly: “Italy is watching with great interest developments in the Far East. Because of Japan’s recent energetic invasion of Italian markets not only in Italy itself but in the Colonies and in the smaller countries bordering the Mediterranean, her attitude is not pro-Japanese.”(4)

Explaining why Italy had militarily reinforced its colonies of Eritrea and Somaliland, Alessandro Lessona, Under-Secretary of Colonies, proclaimed Italy’s fears in a speech at Naples at the end of the year:

In the Far East, the political situation tends to get worse. In the face of the complexity and importance of European interests in this region of the world, Japan, for the first time in history, offers the example of a people of 80,000,000 inhabitants extraordinarily developed economically, industrially and militarily
The birth rate, energy and spirit of sacrifice of the Japanese, the imperious necessity for always seeking new markets—all these combine to make Japan a great danger for Europe. Her pretensions and her force are the axle around which turns all Oriental policy.
The more one restrains the Japanese expansion in the East, the more she will try to expand in other sectors and in other continents. Japan’s activity in Ethiopia proves this.

Lessona ominously added that Africa could well represent the final objective of Japanese expansion:

To draw the Dark Continent into her own orbit would signify for Japan not so much in acquisition of power, as a means of depriving Europe of the possibility of using Africa for the defense of her civilization. (5)

The Japanese understandably reacted. The Yomiuri newspaper in January 1934, for example, complained that Mussolini seemed obsessed with the old "Yellow Peril" theory for a base reason—that is, Italy’s defeat in African markets at Japanese hands. (6)

Romantic Japanese visions (7) and presumed plans for cotton and opium cultivation in the Ethiopian highlands by thousands of Japanese colonists excited observers the world over. Germany’s press in December 1934 insisted that this economic threat also jeopardized white racial supremacy and symbolized the West’s progressive decline. Yellow dolls of Japanese manufacture, Germans lamented, were replacing white dolls in the hands of "Negro" children in Asia and Africa. The crowning psychological effect would be enormous. The Osaka Mainichi & Tokyo Nichi Nichi cynically added that the Germans were reacting hysterically because their toy trade had been the hardest hit among all German industries by Japanese competition. (8)

What we might expect from Nazi Germany, Communist Russia surprisingly underscored. Rejecting its class-based rationalism for passionate nationalism, the Moscow Daily News on January 11, 1935, described Italy’s imperialism and sympathetically editorialized that Italians had sought Ethiopia’s peaceful economic penetration. However, “The reversion of Italian policy in Abyssinia to the old methods of direct seizure is bound up to a considerable degree with the intensification of Japanese economic and political influence in Abyssinia.”(9) The Soviet editorial added that Japan’s increasing influence was fraught with dangers not only for Italy’s interests in Ethiopia but also for British interests in Egypt and the Sudan.  The editorial thereby implied the Kremlin’s belief that Britain should go with Italy and France on the Ethiopian question.

One issue, minor in itself, for many in Italy and elsewhere came to symbolize--and personify--Japanese encroachments . . . a marriage. One particularly hyperventilated account argued that,

[P]lans have been made for effecting mixed marriages between the eligible Japanese settlers (estimated at about 2000 in number) and native Abyssinian women. This declared policy, intended to produce a new race of leaders in the united revolt of the coloured peoples against the white races, was to have been inaugurated by the marriage of Princess Masako, a daughter of the Japanese prince Kurado [Kuroda], to the Ethiopian prince Lij Ayalé [Araya]. (10)

The many articles in newspapers and magazines, especially those appealing to women, showed that the proposed marriage had stirred popular excitement in Japanese. The emotions produced were genuine and have remained etched in some memories to this day. For example, my wife’s grandmother, born in western Japan, grew excited on hearing about my work:

There was a nationwide atmosphere of friendship toward Ethiopia in the 1930s, and I, then a girl’s middle school student, also have a strong impression on the matter. There was a rumor of a marriage between the Ethiopian royal family and the Japanese nobility. I imagined that Ethiopia must have been a wonderful country. The Japanese prewar-generation people still feel closeness to Ethiopia even today. In the 1970s, Japanese people expressed their support for Abeba, an Olympic marathon runner, because he was from Ethiopia. (11)

And in the spring of 1999, a popular quiz show on Japanese television asked a question about the marriage. (12)

How did all of this come to pass? One year after signing a Treaty of Friendship and Commerce with Tokyo in 1930, Ethiopia’s foreign minister, Blaten Geta Heruy, made a grand tour of Japan. The visit dramatized the potentialities of future Ethio-Japanese cooperation in the political, diplomatic, and economic arenas. One Araya Abeba had accompanied Heruy’s embassy. (13)

Impressed with Japan, Araya, seemingly a prince and nephew of the Emperor Hayle Sellase, expressed his desire to marry: "It has been my long-cherished ambition," he explained to a Japanese reporter in February 1934, "to marry a Japanese lady. Of all first-class nations, Japan has the strongest appeal."(14) The original initiative was seemingly his. (15)

Sumioka [Kadooka] Tomoyoshi, (16) a Tokyo lawyer, philo-Ethiopian nationalist, and Pan-Asian activist, stage-managed much of the marriage affair. Heruy had visited him during his 1931 trip to Japan. Sumioka now wished to facilitate Japanese trade and investment in Ethiopia.

Meanwhile, in 1932, two young men had gone to Addis Ababa. (17) One of them, Shoji Yunosuke, had played an important role in Heruy’s reception in 1931. Preaching racial solidarity uniting Ethiopians and Japanese, he approvingly citing a professor who had written: “It is obvious that some superior races moved from West Asia to the Nile basin a long time ago. . . . [I]t is uncontroversial that the Ethiopian people a very long time ago had some racial connections with the Japanese people.”(18) Upon his return to Japan, he explained his relationship with Sumioka:

When I left Ethiopia, the Ethiopian Emperor, who greatly favored Japan, especially permitted his meeting and granted a picture, rhino’s horn, musk, etc., to me. At that time, he entrusted his recent picture as a gift to Mr. Sumioka Tomoyoshi to me, and I handed it to Mr. Sumioka after my return, which was my first acquaintance with him. Since then, his excellent understanding and right belief on racial issues and world statecraft deeply impressed me. I gained an opportunity to be consulted about the Ethiopian marriage issue, as it has progressed, because I fortunately have a close friendship with Prince Araya. (19)

At least from the fall of 1932, Sumioka was eager to find a bride for Araya. Araya soon did tell him to advertise for applicants and from them select suitable candidates. The announcement that Araya was seeking a Japanese bride went out in May 1933 and the first article on the marriage appeared that same month. (20) In his monthly report for June 1933, United States’ Ambassador Joseph Grew noted that for several weeks the Japanese press had carried stories of Araya’s request to have a Japanese bride sent to him. The ambassador mistakenly identified him as a prince and nephew of Hayle Sellase. He added that the press was saying that after his return home his longing for a Japanese maiden was such that he had requested "Imperial sanction" for his marriage to a Japanese. (21)

The wedding was to be held according to Christian rites in April or May 1934, first in Japan and then again on the Prince’s return to Addis Ababa. According to press accounts, the twenty-three-year-old prince was reassuringly light-skinned, monogamous, and Christian. Hence, "Scores of adventurous girls who were willing to be a Princess of Ethiopia answered. . . ," apparently at least twenty in all. (22)

From these, Araya made two preliminary choices. The second was Kabata Shigeko, the twenty-two-year-old, third daughter of Tabata Kametaro, a millionaire businessman of Moji. On the morning of January 21, Sumioka announced as Araya’s first choice, a young woman who had been among the first applicants. (23)

Kuroda Masako, the first choice, was the twenty-three-year-old, second daughter of Viscount Kuroda Hiroyuki of the forestry bureau of the Imperial Household. Viscount Kuroda was descended from the former Lord of Kazusa, a feudal lord in Chiba. She had presented her picture and other credentials to Sumioka without her parents’ knowledge. Despite early objections, her father was soon preparing to visit Ethiopia. The Kuroda family lived in a tiny suburban house, and she was graduated from the Kanto Gakuin Higher Girl’s School in Yodobashi-ku. She spoke English fluently, having been one of the first Japanese girls to take part in an English oratorical contest and to win a prize. At five feet, three inches, she was taller than average. After her enrollment as a candidate to be the "prince’s bride," she studied the habits and customs of Ethiopia through books and conversations with those familiar with conditions there. (24)

In school Kuroda had been a keen athlete who enjoyed swimming, basketball, volleyball, and tennis. In an interview in February 1934, she enthusiastically remarked:

I understand the people of Ethiopia are extremely interested in sports, and I believe that I shall be able to indulge my taste for athletics when I go there. Unfortunately I did not have the opportunity of meeting Prince Abeba [Araya] when he visited Japan a few years ago, but I have firmly decided to go to his country and I am willing to put up with whatever circumstances come along. (25)

Women’s magazines immediately jumped on the topic. For instance, in its March issue Fujin Kurabu [Women’s Club] carried a round table discussion entitled, "Fairyland Ethiopia Will Receive a Bride for the Royal Nephew from Japan" and detailed the process of Sumioka’s selection of the bride. It quoted Kuroda as saying: "When I heard the report of ‘It is decided to be Kuroda. Please take means accordingly,’ my heart was filled with joy, and I exclaimed, ‘Banzai!’"(26)

Reflecting the popular excitement, a set of dolls for the Girls’ Festival (March 3) were made specially for her to take to Africa when she married Araya. The Girl’s Festival is a beloved, traditional holiday, and in their homes girls formally set up dolls surrounded by special sweets. These dolls often pass from mother to daughter. The dolls bore the crest of the Kuroda family and of the prince of Ethiopia. (27)

Throughout 1935, Japanese women continued their interest in Ethiopia. The Fujin Kurabu [Women’s Club] reported on Ethiopia’s condition in its October and November issue. The Shufu no Tomo [Friend of Housewives], also discussed the Ethiopian conflict in its September and October issues. (28)

Beyond the exotic romance, what had stirred such interest in the proposed marriage? Kuroda allowed that with its ever-increasing population Japan would have to found colonies abroad. Wanting to increase the ties of friendship uniting Japan and Ethiopia, she saw herself as the first of many who would emigrate to Ethiopia. (29) Such statements sparked alarm among those, especially in Italy, who feared Japanese competition in East Africa. And, in truth, many in Japan did see in the proposed marriage the opportunity to cut into interests of the colonial powers. Japanese newspapers and nationalists further argued the necessity of uniting the colored races against whites. The marriage would personify this solidarity. (30)

On the other side of the world, a faction of Ethiopia’s intelligentsia, known as the Japanizers, were favoring intermarriage between upper-class Ethiopians and Japanese. These intellectuals for several decades had been imploring Ethiopia to model its modernization along Japanese lines. (31) For example, an Eritrean intellectual and Ethiopian patriot, Blatta Gabra Egziabher, was an early Japanizer. He wrote verses extolling modernization:

Let us learn from the Europeans; let us become strong
So that the enemy may not vanquish us, on the first encounter.
Let us examine our history; let us read the newspaper.
Let us learn languages; let us look at maps.
This is what opens people’s eyes.
Darkness has gone; dawn has come.
It is a disgrace to sleep by day.

Modernization, for the sake of national strength, found expression in another of his poems, which declared,

He who accepts it, fears no one.
He will become like Japan, strong in everything. (32)

Commercial and economic negotiations were the tangible, practical result of such talk. One Japanese business enterprise became entwined in international diplomacy to the injury of both Japan and Ethiopia. Popularly known as Nikkei-Sha, the Nagasaki Echiopia Keizai Chosa-kai Nikkei-Sha [Nagasaki Association for Economic Investigation of Ethiopia] had been founded in 1932 in Nagasaki to conduct import/export operations with Ethiopia. Its director, Kitagawa Takashi, had gone to Ethiopia that same year. In September 1933, he received permission to negotiate a deal with Ethiopia. A glib-talking and unscrupulous fixer, he negotiated with Heruy for authorization on: the rights to use 500,000 hectares of land in Ethiopia; a permit to grow cotton, tobacco, tea, green tea, rice, wheat, fruit trees, and vegetables; a permit to grow medicinal plants; a grant of fifteen hectares of land for each immigrant Japanese family; and 1,000 hectares of land next to Addis Ababa for a Japanese investigation mission to examine what plants could be grown in Ethiopia. Kitagawa managed little but to earn Ethiopia and Japan international suspicion. His scheme provoked Great Britain, France, the USSR, and, especially, Italy. (33) Some drew the conclusion that Hayle Sellase, satisfied with the progress of the marriage idea, decided to grant 1,600,000 acres to Japan and was planning to permit Japanese immigration. (34)

Not all Japanese were dizzy with the marriage fever. On January 18, 1934, Juo Hyoron [Free Critics] published an article tying the marriage to the international discord. In part it read:

Although we do not have any ambitions in Ethiopia, countries such as Italy, France, and England which possess close and unalienable interests in Ethiopia, will most certainly understand the royal engagement as a part of Japan’s African ambitions, including colonization. Though England and France are unworthy of any trust in a crisis, Italy as well as Germany are still somewhat the allies of an isolated Japan. It would be capricious of Japan to undertake an adventure that could damage Italy’s feelings.
We should firmly eliminate any ambitions toward Ethiopia and warn against rumors for the sake of the integrity of the Japanese lady who is to be sacrificed for concessions worth only 500,000 yen. . . .(35)

Shoji objected to such logic. He argued that Japan could not count on Italy as an ally: those who could write such things were no better than spies purveying treason. (36)

The Japanese government did not agree with Shoji. Tokyo could not allow a free hand in Ethiopia to ambitious, pan-Asiatic adventurers such as Kitagawa. Matters reached the point when Japan’s Gaimusho [foreign ministry] in February 1934 decided to send a high-ranking officer to investigate conditions in Ethiopia. The Second Division of the Trade Section explained why:

Reports say that the Ethiopian government intends to approve a wide land lease to Japanese people, and that Ethiopian royal family wishes to arrange a marriage with a Japanese noble family. Ethiopia recently has shown a pro-Japanese attitude. . . . When the Japanese people extend their business to Ethiopia, we need to understand the domestic conditions of this country and carefully consider its delicate international position. Otherwise, our plans will fail, or we will unnecessarily invite the envy and misunderstanding of other major countries. Such a result will negatively influence future relations between our two countries. . . .(37)

To go, the Gaimusho chose Tsuchida Yutaka, a Gaimusho secretary, who had described Ethiopians as half-black Semites, one-third of whom formed the traditional ruling class and believed in Christianity. The other two-thirds, he added, were either Muslim or non-religious. Often barbaric, Ethiopians were lazy, uncultured, and "benign."(38) Like so many Japanese in government, he was not one to excessively romanticize any presumed racial solidarity binding the Japanese with the Ethiopians.

In any case, he arrived in Ethiopia just in time. He reported that the Ethiopians no longer trusted the Japanese as they had before. They complained that Japan’s press had written too much on the Nikkei-Sha and marriage affairs. An irresponsible press and the Anti-Opium Bureau of the League of Nations had treated the first as if Ethiopia had signed a concession for cultivating opium. The second, presented as if it was the heir to the throne who wanted to marry, had led to an embarrassing complaint from Mussolini to Hayle Sellase. (39) An exasperated Heruy spoke of the marriage rumors as

Fairy-tales! Goodness knows where they sprang from! . . .
It is also rumoured, probably from the same source, that Japan is settling peasants in Abyssinia, some of whom are to work on cotton plantations. Others are to become soldiers for an expect war. Two hundred thousand is the number mentioned. Now, I ask you, have you seen or heard any sign of this Japanese invasion in the country itself? At the moment there are not 200,000 nor 2,000 but only 4 Japanese in the whole of Abyssinia. There is still no Japanese Legation and our four Japanese guests are little merchants who have built a small shop where they sell Japanese goods to compete with the cheap Czech glassware the Galli and Somali women like so much. As far as I can tell, this outpost of the Japanese invasion is not doing well, and its owners are thinking of leaving the country. (40)

Difficulties rose to the point at the end of February 1934, when Kuroda defensively asserted: "I will go to Ethiopia even in the capacity of a private citizen, if the Imperial Household authorities should disapprove of my trip."(41)

At that time, her mother admitted that the Imperial Household Department had not yet sanctioned her daughter’s betrothal or proposed trip to Ethiopia. She added that Araya had been, "scheduled to visit Japan in May of this year, but his trip has been indefinitely postponed. No direct word has been received from the Royal Family of Ethiopia, but Mr. Sumioka, a lawyer, is negotiating the matter."(42)

Not misled by the publicity hullabaloo, the American embassy in Tokyo reported in February 1934 that the Japanese government had provided little information on the marriage and disparaged its political significance. (43) The next month, the embassy reported that the marriage was about to fall through because of official Japanese opposition. The embassy added that the press continued to write colorful stories. As a new variation, the Tokyo Hochi had written that Ethiopia’s imperial family had become so interested in Japan that it would request a bride for the crown prince. The newspaper gave as its source a letter written by a Japanese cook employed by Ethiopia’s Emperor! (44)

Providing more reliable information, Haniyu Chotaro, a businessman from Kamakura, had spent five months in Ethiopia at the Gaimusho’s request. On his return in April 1934, he publicly discussed the available commercial opportunities. He then declared that the marriage was receiving little attention in Ethiopia while in Japan it had created a public sensation. His comments were hardly encouraging:

This matter is delicate from a viewpoint of the international situation, . . .
Prince Ababa [Araya] is called a Prince only in Japan. In Ethiopia, he is called Lij Ababa, and the word Lij means "lord" in English. There are only three Princes of the Blood in Ethiopia. The Japanese Foreign Office has nothing to do with this marriage. Some time ago, an Italian newspaper sarcastically remarked that Japan intends to invade Africa with "kisses between the dark and the black by having a daughter of a Japanese peer married to an Ethiopian." The Ethiopian press from the outset has been taciturn on the matter. If Miss Kuroda really wants to marry Ababa, she had better, I think, personally inspect the actual conditions of Ethiopia. (45)

Sound comments and advice. Yet, his visit unintentionally added fuel to the burning concerns over the political and economic implications of Japan’s encroachments into Northeast Africa. Inspired by the visit, in what appears to be a semi-official letter in early March 1934, Jacob Adol Mar, self-proclaimed, retired counselor of state and friend of Ethiopia’s foreign minister, wrote to "C. Hanew" [Haniyu Chotaro].  He declared that all "logical thinking" Ethiopians wanted to see the Japanese come to Ethiopia for industrial and commercial purposes. Mar proposed an extensive set of concessions for Japanese commercial and business enterprises. (46)

Ethiopia, he wrote, felt squeezed among the colonies of Britain, France, and Italy.  He added, "In this critical situation we all hope that the presence of many Japanese may encourage Your Government to give us a political help in difficult circumstances." He lamented the "regrettable faults" by those in both Ethiopia and Japan, which allowed European powers to oppose Ethio-Japanese friendship. All important Ethiopian governmental officers had received instructions against making such missteps, but the Ethiopians feared that Japanese journalists, manufacturers, and traders knew so little about Ethiopia that new blunders might again trouble relations between Ethiopia and Japan. (47)

Therefore, continued Mar, his friends had suggested that he go to Japan to speak publicly to build sympathy for Ethiopia. He proposed that he would explain to the Gaimusho the best way to open political relations with Ethiopia and how Japan’s bankers, exporters, and manufacturers could set up successful enterprises. The necessary first step would be to establish an Imperial Legation in Addis Ababa. The Japanese could do this cheaply--one diplomat would be enough, and he could get a house at low rent from Ethiopia’s government. Mar could act officially as an adviser for Japan’s legation. Mar thought that the legation’s permanent representative ought to be in Ethiopia at beginning of Japan’s business activity. If Tokyo could not send him immediately, Mar suggested letting an important merchant act as a consul or consul general until his arrival. (48)

Presumably unaware of Mar’s proposal, Rome’s embassy in Tokyo on Saturday afternoon, October 6, 1934, issued a communiqué rejecting the ideas that Italy was interested in aggression against Ethiopia or the proposed marriage.

The Italian Government hold none but friendly intentions towards the Ethiopian Government with which Italy has a treaty of amity since 1928. Italy intends to continue with Ethiopia the most friendly relations as a necessary basis for further increasing such mutual relations politically and economically.

The Italian Embassy seizes this opportunity to formally deny that the Italian Government has ever and in any way been interested in the question of a proposed marriage between a notable Abyssinian and a Japanese young lady. (49)

Despite these assurances, the projected marriage between the "wealthy" Japanese girl and the Ethiopian "prince" was quashed, many thought by Italy’s diplomatic pressure. (50) The Economist (London) in December 1934, repeated that it had required Italian diplomatic pressure to quash the projected Ethio-Japanese marriage. (51) Likewise charged Kato Kanju, president of the National Council of Trade Unions of Japan, the largest group of workers in the country. While visiting the United States in July 1935, he claimed that Mussolini had blocked the marriage. (52) The New York Times did not regard the idea as illogical. (53) Some believed that Emperor Hirohito was bitter with Italians because their protests had broken off the proposed marriage. (54)

Resonating fears of Japanese competition, Japan’s competitors in East Africa continued to raise the marriage issue long after it was dead. In a December 1934 meeting with Sugimura Yotaro, Japan’s new ambassador, Mussolini linked it to many contentious issues: "Japan is actively supplying weapons and ammunition to Ethiopia, sending a princess, and a newspaper in Tokyo is vigorously maneuvering Japanese-Ethiopian friendship."(55)

Sugimura, who had represented his government at Geneva when Japan withdrew from the League of Nations, soon thereafter spoke with La Tribuna of Rome. The ambassador endeavored to dispel suspicions of conflicting Italo-Japanese interests in Asia and Africa. He emphatically denied charges that Japan’s Army had sent instructors to Ethiopia. Denigrating Japan’s economic penetration of Ethiopia, Sugimura explained that middlemen, "mostly Jewish," had purchased goods at Kobe that were finding their way into Ethiopia "by means of these same middlemen and not by direct importation."(56) Sugimura also denied that there was any foundation for the rumor of a projected marriage between a Japanese princess and an Ethiopian prince. On the Far East, Sugimura said that he was convinced that Italy could pursue its interests in that field without fear of Japanese opposition. There was a vast Chinese market to exploit, the Japanese ambassador pointed out. He opined that Japan and Italy might well come to a reciprocal agreement for the exchange of goods, which would be profitable to both. (57)

In truth, beyond Japanese exports to Ethiopia, most of which went through Indian merchants, there was little direct contact between the two nations. In 1932, fifteen Japanese had settled in Ethiopia, and in 1933 seven more had arrived. In 1934, four more. Most, however, did not stay long, leaving after their enterprises had failed. For example, although Nikkei-Sha got agricultural concessions from Ethiopian, failing to find the necessary capital, it could not exploit them and went out of business after six months. Tsuchida Yutaka noted that not many Japanese visited Ethiopia: in the summer of 1934, there were only four including himself. In 1935, only three. In August 1935, no Japanese shipping company included Djibouti in its list of ports of call. (58)

The New York Times on July 11, 1935, summed up the situation nicely: Japan’s economic interests in Ethiopia were new and still small; Japan still had no legation in Addis Ababa and Ethiopia had no representative in Tokyo; the number of Japanese residents in Ethiopia was small; reports of Japanese capitalists having gained concessions for cotton growing in Ethiopia were unfounded; and stories that an Ethiopian prince had been seeking to marry a Japanese princess were groundless. (59)

The principals, Kuroda, Araya, Shoji, and Sumioka moved off center stage. Mistaken for a communist, Kuroda was taken to the Ueno police station in Tokyo on the night of July 24, 1935. The problem began when a policeman noted a suspicious-looking woman in black afternoon dress walking up and down the street near Ueno Park for two hours until about 8:00 p.m. The policeman disguised himself as a worker and arrested her. As it turned out, she had earlier reported to him that she had lost her purse containing about ¥5. She had borrowed 20 sen from him but had given a false name—therefore the trouble. Even after she had given her real name and had explained that she had been waiting for a friend, the policeman was still suspicious and took her in. She was, however, shortly released. (60)

In August, the Osaka Mainichi and Shoji sponsored a round table discussion in Addis Ababa and invited prominent Ethiopians including Heruy. (61) The next month as war was ready to break out, Araya suggested that Japan obtain concessions in Ethiopia, according to the Nichi Nichi correspondent at Addis Ababa. He said that Ethiopia would gladly grant such concessions to Japan for industrial development. The Emperor was ready to approve such grants and Araya offered his services as an intermediary. (62) Later, in 1943, Araya attended a New York City meeting of the Ethiopian World Federation and thereafter became involved in its internal politics. (63)

The Japan Advertiser of March 28, 1936, reported that Sumioka had been awarded the Commander Class of the Order of Menelik II by Emperor Hayle Sellase. In his letter of thanks, Sumioka praised the good will of the Japanese people toward Ethiopia and his own conviction that Ethiopia’s brave army would defeat Italy. (64) A month later, Hayle Sellase fled his country.

Meanwhile, only two months after the marriage affair had been put to bed, a military mission headed by Marshal Pietro Badoglio, chief of Italy’s General Staff, visited Eritrea to begin planning Ethiopia’s conquest. (65)

The summer of 1935 had plumbed the depths of Italo-Japanese relations, especially during the so-called Sugimura Affair of July. The contretemps was born of the Gaimusho’s inept attempts to "clarify" Ambassador Sugimura’s assiduous efforts to reassure Mussolini about Japan’s interests in Ethiopia. In smoothing over the ruffled feathers, Rome and Tokyo began building in August the foundation for their alliance that ultimately went to war in 1941. (66) As part of that process and to recognize Italy’s control over Ethiopia, Japan’s government transformed its newly created Legation in Addis Ababa into a Consulate General. In return, Italy’s foreign minister, Galeazzo Ciano, promised to protect Japanese interests there. As if to emphasize that suspicions lingered, he simultaneously referred to the proposed marriage and the Negus’ desire to draw closer to Japan. In the end, Rome broke its promises. But no matter. Japan had accepted its exclusion from Ethiopia--Japan had left Ethiopia at the marriage altar to elope with Italy. (67)

ENDNOTES
1. E-mail: From Luke Shepherd Roberts, Mar. 20, 96, 02:17:27 p.m. -0800.
2. J. Calvitt Clarke III, "Periphery and Crossroads: Ethiopia and World Diplomacy, 1934-36," Ethiopia in Broader Perspective: Papers of the XIIIth International Conference of Ethiopian Studies, 3 vols., K. E. Fukui and M. Shigeta, eds. (Kyoto: Shokado Book Sellers, 1997), 1: 699-712.
3. See, e.g., Mario dei Gaslini, "Il Giappone nel’economia Etiopica" [Japan in the Ethiopian Economy], in Federazione Provinciale Fascista Milanese, Corso di Preparazione politica per i giovani [Course of Political Preparation for Youths] Riassunti dello lezioni tenute nel scondo trimestre (Milan: Tipografia del "Popolo d’Italia," 1935), 99-107.
4. Italy (Naval Attaché), 2/20/34: National Archives (College Park, MD), Decimal File [hereafter cited as NA] 765.94/4.
5. "Italy Fears Oriental Power Seeks to Win Africa Away from European Nations, "New York Times, Dec. 2, 1934, 28: 1.
6. "Japanese Press Opinions," Japan Times, Jan. 30, 1934, 8.
7. See, e.g., Oyama Ujiro, Echiopia Tanpo Hokoku [Report on a Visit to Ethiopia] (Tokyo: Shunnan-sha, 1934); Oyama Ujiro, Abyssinia Jijo, Madagascaru Jijo, Porutoraru ryo Higashi Africa Jijo [The Situation of Abyssinia, of Madagascar, and of Portuguese East Africa] (Tokyo: Foreign Ministry, 1928); Aminako Yasuhiro, Fugen Echiopia Teikoku no Zenbo [The Whole Story of the Ethiopian Empire: Source of Wealth] (Tokyo: Osaka-sho, 1934); Shoji Yunosuke, Echiopia Kekkon Mondai wa Donaru, Kaisho ka? Ina!!!: Kekkon Mondai o Shudai to shite Echiopia no Shinso o Katari Kokumin no Saikakunin [What Will Happen to the Ethiopian Marriage Issue, Cancellation? or Not!!!: I Request the Recognition of the (Japanese) Nation by Narrating the Truth of Ethiopia with the Marriage Issue as the Central Theme] (Tokyo: Seikyo Sha, 1934); Tsuchida Yutaka, "Echiopia o Miru" [Viewing Ethiopia] Chuo Koron [Center for Opinion Leaders] 50 (Nov. 1935): 308-15; and Tsurumi Yusuke and Komai Shigetsugu, Fuun no Rutsubo Echiopia [A Whirlwind in Ethiopia] (Tokyo: Yashima Shobo, 1935). Okakura Takashi and Kitagawa Katsuhiko in Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi: Meiji-ki kara Dainiji Sekai Taisen-ki made [History of Japanese-African Relations: From the Meiji Period to the Second World War Period] (Tokyo: Dobun-kan, 1993), 42, discuss this romanticism. For example, the Dai Tsuran Seinen Domei [Youth League of Great Turan] which included Sumioka Tomoyoshi and Shoji Yunosuke as central members, Aikoku Seinen Renmei [Youth Union of Nationalist], Dai Nihon Seisan-to [Great Japan Manufacturers] Kokusui Taishu-to Teishin-tai [Volunteers of Nationalistic Populace Party], and Dai Ajia-shugi Kyokai [Society of Pan Asianism] expressed support for Ethiopia. Turan refers to the Turan Plateau--the claimed ancestral home of both the Japanese and Ethiopian peoples, that is located between Altai Mountains and the Caspian Sea. When Heruy visited Japan, Sumioka invited him to his house and explained that there were many common vocabulary words between Japanese and Ethiopia’s Amhara language. He also wrote a letter to Heruy: “[T]here is a description in the Old Testament of same national roots of Ethiopians and Japanese. Chapter 10 of the Genesis records that the brave Japanese and Ethiopian peoples are the descendants of Yawan, a son of the third son, Yabete, of Noa. (42-43).” Okakura and Kitagawa describe these movements as a racialist and anti-white (43). My thanks to Mariko A. Clarke who has translated these Japanese materials and guided me through the Gaimusho’s archives in Tokyo.
8. "White Race Menaced," Osaka Mainichi & Tokyo Nichi Nichi, Dec. 22, 1934, 4g.
9. F. Korradov, "Italian Expansion In Abyssinia," Moscow Daily News, Jan. 11, 1935, 2f-3b. For more on this interpretation, see J. Calvitt Clarke III, "Japan and Italy Squabble Over Ethiopia: The Sugimura Affair of July 1935," paper presented to the Florida Conference of Historians, Daytona Beach, FL, March 12-14, 1998; and Clarke, "Periphery and Crossroads," 1: 699-712.
10. Roman Procházka, Abyssinia: The Powder Barrel (London: British International News Agency, 1936), 60. Translated from the German edition of 1935, this book was printed in Austria.
11. Makiuchi Yoshiko, Spr. 1998.
12. Personal communication from Mark Caprio, April 9, 1999.
13. Furukawa Tetsushi, "Japan’s Political Relations with Ethiopia, 1920s-1960s: A Historical Overview," unpublished paper presented to the 35th Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association, Seattle, WA, Nov. 20-23, 1992. Araya’s father was Ato Abbaba Ayalawarq, the cousin of Haile Selassie, and he was the brother of Wayzaro Mazelaqiyawarqa-Awarq, the mother of Ras Emeru. His grandmother was Wayzaro Eheta-Maryam-Walda-Mikael, the sister of Ras Makonnen. See Aoki Sumio and Kurimoto Eisei, "Japanese Interest in Ethiopia (1868-1940): Chronology and Bibliography," Ethiopia in Broader Perspective, 1: 714, 723. Also see Yamada Kazuhiro, Masukaru no Hanayome: Maboroshi no Echiopia Ojihi [Bride of Mascar: Phantom of an Ethiopian Consort] (Tokyo: Asahi Shinbun-Sha, 1998), 59-64, 92-96, 105.
14. "Prince Advertises for Bride in Japan," New York Times, Feb. 18, 1934, IV, 8:6. For Heruy’s comments on Japanese women, see Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 114.
15. Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 113, 123, 230-33.
16. The Chinese characters representing his name may be transliterated into English as either "Kadooka" or "Sumioka."
17. See Aoki and Kurimoto, "Japanese Interest in Ethiopia," 1: 714; Heruy Walde Sellassie, Dai Nippon [Great Japan], trans. Oreste Vaccari and Enko Vaccari (Tokyo: Eibunpo Tsuron, 1934), 3. This is the Japanese translation of Mahdere Berhan Ha-Ager Japon [The Source of Light, the Country of Japan] (Addis Ababa, 1932), 91-99. See also Okakura and Kitagawa, Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi, 33, 36-37.
18. Shoji, Echiopia Kekkon Mondai, 5. Shoji wrote this article to correct rampant misinformation and to "report a true picture of the marriage issue and Ethiopia," which he could do because "I was luckily permitted to read correspondence concerning the marriage issue." From the Introduction. Also see Aoki and Kurimoto, "Japanese Interest in Ethiopia," 1: 724. The whole statement in Shoji by Dr. Kogami (Tonoue) Komanosuke of Kyushu Imperial University to the Fukuoka Nichi Nichi newspaper on November 17, 1931, is instructive:

It is obvious that some superior races moved from West Asia to the Nile basin a long time ago. It should be seen as an old mystery from which place our race originated. However, as I have already argued in my publication. Nihon Minzoku [Japanese People], I believe that our race started in the basin of Tigris-Euphrates in West Asia by surveying studies of the Asian continent’s ancient history, languages, and anthropology. I believe that the ancient Hyksos tribe had racial connection with our ancestors. Seeing names of places around the basin of the Nile today, I cannot help judging that they were named by the tribe which was our ancestor. For instance, the mountain region of Ethiopia is called Amuhara, which must correspond to our Amahara (a short term for Takamagahara). Also names like kashi, koshi, and kushi around the Nile basin are clearly named by the tribe migrated from West Asia. I think that our place names, kashi, koshi, kushi (note: place names as Tsukushi, Kushiro, and Echizen, Ecchu, Echigo in Etsu no Kuni, and personal names like Kushimoto, Kishi, Kusumoto, Etsuda, etc.) are derived from the same etymological origin. Therefore, it is uncontroversial that the Ethiopian people very long time ago had some racial connections with the Japanese people.

19. Shoji, Echiopia Kekkon Mondai, from the Introduction.
20. Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 126.
21. Japan (Grew), 7/6/33: NA 894.00 P.R./67.
22. "Masako Kuroda Chosen to Wed Ethiopian Prince," Japan Times, Jan. 21, 1934, 1; "Prince Advertises for Bride in Japan," New York Times, Feb. 18, 1934, IV, 8:6; Japan (Grew), 7/6/33: NA 894.00 P.R./67; Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 128.
23. "Masako Kuroda Chosen to Wed Ethiopian Prince," Japan Times, Jan. 21, 1934,1; "Prince Advertises for Bride in Japan," New York Times, Feb. 18, 1934, IV, 8:6. For Kuroda’s application, see Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 128-29.
24. "Masako Kuroda Chosen to Wed Ethiopian Prince," Japan Times, Jan. 21, 1934, 1; "Utopia In Ethiopia," ibid., Feb. 23, 1934, 8de; "Prince Advertises for Bride in Japan," New York Times, Feb. 18, 1934, IV, 8:6; Japan (Grew), 2/6/34: NA 894.00 P.R./74; Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 15-19.
25. "Miss Kuroda Will Visit Ethiopia Even Though Trip Is Disapproved in Japan," Japan Times, Feb. 25, 1934, 1de.
26. Okakura and Kitagawa, Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi, 37-38.
27. "Utopia In Ethiopia: An Ancient Empire Now on the Highroad of Reorganization and Rebirth," Japan Times, Feb. 23, 1934, 8de.
28. Okakura and Kitagawa, Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi, 38-39. See also Unno Yoshiro, "Dainiji Itaria-Echiopia Senso to Nihon," [The Second Italo-Ethiopian War and Japan] Hosei Riron 16 (Jan. 1984): 190.
29. "Utopia In Ethiopia," Japan Times, Feb. 23, 1934, 8de.
30. Kurosawa to Hirota, 1/24/36: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan [Record Office, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, hereafter cited as Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo)] A461 ET/I1, vol. 6. Some African Americans also saw the marriage as heralding the day of Asian-African global unity. The Chicago Defender argued, not entirely correctly, that intermarriage was common and acceptable to both races, and that Japanese internationalists had set their hearts on uniting these two ancient houses to forge a strong union between Japan and Ethiopia. "Ethiopian, Italian Armies Face Each Other In Africa," Chicago Defender, July 13, 1935.
31. Ernest Allen, "When Japan Was ‘Champion of the Darker Races’: Satokata Takahashi and the Flowering of Black Messianic Nationalism," The Black Scholar 24 (Win. 1994): 30: Ladislas Farago, Abyssinia on the Eve (New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1935), 70-76; Addis Hiwet, Ethiopia: from Autocracy to Revolution (London: review of African Political Economy, 1975), 68-76; and Richard Bradshaw, "Japan and European Colonialism in Africa 1800-1937" (Ph.D. dissertation, Ohio University, 1992), 298-306.
32. Richard Pankhurst, "History of Education, Printing and Literacy in Ethiopia. 9: Educational Advances in Menilek’s Day," Addis Tribune, Oct. 2, 1998, http://addistribune.ethiopiaonline.net/Archives/1998/10/02-10-98/Hist-313.htm. Some Europeans did not assume this collaboration to be benign. See, e.g., Procházka, Abyssinia, 4, who writes that the Japanizers, aided and abetted by the government, were systematically "fostering hatred of the white peoples...." Nothing good can result: “The application of European methods of education to the coloured peoples is bearing tragic and dangerous fruits, more particularly in the cases in which the natives are not under the rule and control of white people but have a free hand to conceive and follow up any fatal policy to which their position as a sovereign native state entitles them.
33. Tokyo to Blatin Geta Heruy, 9/4/33; Note to Kitagawa, 9/28/33: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo) E424 1-3-1.
34. Okakura and Kitagawa, Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi, 37.
35. Shoji, Echiopia Kekkon Mondai, 14-15.
36. Ibid., 15.
37. Taura Masanori, "Nihon-Echiopia kankei ni miru 1930 nen tsusho gaiko no iso" [A Phase of the 1930 Commercial Diplomacy in the Japanese-Ethiopian Relations], Seifu to Minkan [Government and Civilians], Nenpo, Kindai Nihon Kenkyu [Annual Report, Study of Modern Japan], 17 (1995): 141-170, quote, 154.
38. Okakura and Kitagawa, Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi, 21.
39. Ishihara Hideko, "First Contacts Between Ethiopia and Japan," unpublished paper presented to the XIIIth International Conference of Ethiopian Studies, Kyoto, Japan, Dec. 1997.
40. Farago, Abyssinia, 128.
41. "Miss Kuroda Will Visit Ethiopia Even Though Trip Is Disapproved in Japan," Japan Times, Feb. 25, 1934, 1de. For more on these difficulties, see Yamada, Masukaru no Hanayome, 165-66.
42. Ibid.
43. Japan (Grew), 2/6/34: NA 894.00 P.R./74.
44. Japan (Grew), 3/8/34: NA 894.00 P.R./75.
45. "Ethiopia Promising Market for Japanese Goods," Japan Times, Apr. 22, 1934, fg.
46. Mar to Hanew, 3/4/34: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo) M130 1-1-2. Jacob Adol Mar’s father was Johannes Mayer, a German Protestant missionary who had gone to Ethiopia in 1856 and worked for Emperor Tewodros II. In 1859, he married at Magdala an Ethiopian who was related to the family of Negus Mickael from Wollo. In 1868, Mayer and his wife were among the captives of Tewodros in Magdala, until released by the British army. In 1869 he returned to Ethiopia and worked closely in Ankober with the future emperor Menelik II. In 1881, he settled in the southern province of Bale and opened a mission, which remained open until 1886 when Emperor Johannes IV expelled all foreign missionaries. Jacob Adolf was born in the province of Bale in 1881, the youngest of eight children. The whole family left Ethiopia for Germany where Jacob Adolf completed his studies. His features were those of an Amhara, and he fluently spoke Amharic, Danakil, German, and French. Around 1904, he returned to Ethiopia and served in the governments of Emperor Menelik, Lij Iyassu, and Empress Zawditu. Under Menelik, he was a financial controller of the imperial treasury; he then participated in creating the unsuccessful Bank for the Development of Trade and Agriculture in Abyssinia. Under Lij Iyassu, he worked as a city counselor of Addis Ababa and then was appointed as a state counselor around 1914. He owned the largest German agricultural concession before the First World War in Ethiopia. The plantation was located in the Awash valley and consisted of 51,000 acres of land. He probably received this concession around 1910 because of his links with Emperor Menelik. Close to the German legation, the French legation in 1917 explained that he was among the troublesome characters whom should be expelled from Ethiopia to improve relations with the Ethiopian government. At the demand of Ras Tafari, Mar wrote a report on reforming Ethiopia’s foreign ministry. In Ethiopia he was known as Jacob Adol Mar, and a Belgian administrative document shows that in 1923 he officially changed his name from Jacob Adolf Mayer to the more Ethiopian form. In 1923, he departed for Brussels and worked for some years in Ethiopia’s consulate in Belgium. In 1933 or 1934, he returned for the last time to Ethiopia. Political differences with Haile Selassie and his close relationship with Lij Iyassu led to his exile and the loss of his concession. Thereafter, he sought to recover this land, including, going to Rome to secure recognition of his claims in 1936. He finished his life in Paris. Makeda Ketcham to Jay Clarke, personal letter, Addis Ababa, March 25, 1998. Ms. Ketcham is the granddaughter of Jacob Adol Mar. See Bairu Tafla. Ethiopia and Germany: Cultural, Political and Economic Relations, 1871-1936 (Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner Verlag GMBH, 1981), 174.
47. Mar to Hanew, 3/4/34: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo) M130 1-1-2.
48. Ibid.
49. "Italian Embassy Denies Rumors. Says Ethiopia and Italy On Best of Terms; Refers to Romance." Japan Times, Oct. 7, 1934, 1e; Japan (Grew), 11/12/34: NA 894.00 P.R./83.
50. Japan (Grew), 11/12/34: NA 894.00 P.R./83; "Mussolini Mobilizes Credit to Stabilize Lira," Osaka Mainichi & Tokyo Nichi Nichi, Dec. 18, 1934, 7d-e. "Wealthy" was used by the communist press; see "Imperialism in Abyssinia," International Press Correspondence (Dec. 22, 1934): 1722-23.
51. "Mussolini Mobilizes Credit to Stabilize Lira. Abyssinia Will Be Drawn to Japan for Safety." Osaka Mainichi & Tokyo Nichi Nichi, Dec. 18, 1934, 7d-e.
52. "Labor Leader of Japan Here to View Problems," Chicago Defender, July 13, 1935.
53. "Abyssinian Attack Is Feared by Italy," New York Times, Sept. 9, 1934, 6:2; Furukawa, "Japan’s Political Relations;" Furukawa Tetsushi, "Japanese-Ethiopian Relations in the 1920-30s: The Rise and Fall of ‘Sentimental’ Relations," paper presented at the 34th Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association, St. Louis, MO, Nov. 1991.
54. "Ethiopian, Italian Armies Face Each Other In Africa," Chicago Defender, July 13, 1935.
55. Okakura and Kitagawa, Nihon-Afurika Koryu-shi, 39. For a later example of the continuing rankle, see Kurosawa to Hirota, 1/24/36: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan, A461 ET/I1, vol. 6.
56. For a recent monograph on one aspect of Japanese views toward Jews, see Pamela Rotner Sakamoto, Japanese Diplomats and Jewish Refugees: A World War II Dilemma (Westport, CT: Praeger, 1998).
57. Italy (Kirk), 1/25/35: NA 765.94/9. La Revue du Pacific of February 15, 1935, printed another of Sugimura’s denials of reports regarding a prospective marriage of a Japanese "princess" with an Ethiopian "prince." France (Naval Attaché), 3/13/35: NA 765.94/10.
58. Tsuchida, "Echiopia o Miru," 312; Shoji Yunosuke, "Abyssinia Attempting to Modernize," Osaka Mainichi & Tokyo Nichi Nichi, Aug. 18, 1935, 4bd; Ishihara, "First Contacts;" Adrien Zervos, L’Empire d’Ethiopie: Le Miroir de L’Ethiopie Moderne 1906-1935 (Alexandria, Egypt: Impr. de l’Ecole professionnelle des freres, 1936), 483-84.
59. Hugh Byas, "Japan Is Shunning Dispute in Africa," New York Times, July 11, 1935, 12:3. Iranian papers at the end of summer added their voices to this song. Okamoto (Iran) to Hirota, Report No. 123, 8/26/35: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo) A461 ET/I1, vol. 2. Earlier, the Cape Times in January 1935, had concluded that there were no cotton concessions, that Ethiopia’s laws and religion prevented any marriage between a Japanese princess and an Ethiopian prince, and that no such marriage had been requested in any case. The newspaper insisted that nearly all rumors of Japanese intentions had been started in Rome. "Japanese and Abyssinia," Cape Times, Jan. 4, 1935, in Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo) E424 1-3-1.
An article from a Greek newspaper of January 23, 1936, entitled "Japanese Intentions in Ethiopia--Racial Unity" explained that to smooth out commercial and political relations between Japan and Ethiopia and to cut into the interests of other states in Ethiopia, there had been a rumor of marriage between an Ethiopian prince and a Japanese princess. Japanese newspapers had advocated the necessity of unity among colored races against whites, mostly concerning the Chinese issue although in Ethiopia as well. Charge d’affaires in Greece, Kurosawa to Hirota, Report No. 18, 1/24/36: A461 ET/I1, vol. 6
60. "Miss Kuroda Arrested," Osaka Mainichi & Tokyo Nichi Nichi, July 26, 1935, 3c.
61. Furukawa, "Japan’s Political Relations."
62. "Wants Grant to Japan," New York Times, Sept. 2, 1935, 5:3.
63. Roi Ottley, ‘New World A-Coming’: Inside Black America (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1943), 42.
64. Japan (Grew), 4/16/36: NA 894.00 P.R./100.
65. A. J. Barker, The Civilizing Mission: The Italo-Ethiopian War, 1935-6 (London: Cassell, 1968), 11.
66. Clarke, "Japan and Italy Squabble." See "Italy and the Far East," 2 vols. (New York: International Secretariat. Institute of Pacific Relations, 1939) for an analysis of the progress of Italo-Japanese relations, esp. 1: 16-20, which specifically discusses the Italo-Ethiopian War.
67. "Il Giappone riconosce l’Impero," Giornale d’Italia, Dec. 3, 1936: Gaimusho Gaiko Shiryo Kan (Tokyo) M130 1-1-2.

Return to Jay Clarke’s Curriculum Vitae
Return to Jacksonville University’s Home Page